• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Emerging Scholars Blog

InterVarsity's Emerging Scholars Network

DONATE
  • Home
  • About Us
    • About Our Bloggers
    • Commenting Policy
  • Reading Lists
  • Scholar’s Compass
    • Scholar’s Compass Booklet
    • View Recent Posts
  • Connect
    • Membership
    • Events
    • Donate
    • Contact Us

Scholar's Call

A Christian Mathematician’s Apology: Redeeming the Discipline

Katerina Holmes at Pexels

When Matt Lunsford decided to write on what it means to be a Christian in Mathematics, he modeled his extended essay, A Christian Mathematician’s Apology, after an earlier essay, A Mathematician’s Apology, by G. H. Hardy. This is the third of four parts, the first describing finding his vocation and the second on the integrated life. Building on his ideas of the integrated life, in this article Matt outlines his ideas of what “redeeming the discipline” looks like for him as a mathematician.

While freedom of exploration and source of motivation are clear distinctives for the Christian mathematician, I do not believe that either is the core distinction. Christians are called to live their lives under the Lordship of Christ. This call is for an integrated life, where both piety and intellectual activity are accountable to Christ. As academicians, this means that even our scholarly pursuits should be subject to the Lordship of Christ. In the preface of On Stories, Walter Hooper, the custodian of C. S. Lewis’s works after his death, writes this about Lewis:

“Whether the reader of Lewis’s books is or is not a Christian, it ought to be said here that Lewis’s conversion just was the chief watershed in his life. There was no nook or cranny of his being that it did not eventually reach and transform” (xiv).

This provocative quote goads me to ask a question of myself. Have I allowed the Lordship of Christ to penetrate and transform all areas of life, especially that prideful area of expertise I achieved in mathematics? I find this to be the core of it all.

So the integrated life is a personal journey. It is not formulaic. One size does not fit all. The question of “how do I live an integrated life?” is not just another academic problem to be solved. It cannot be answered solely by reading the “right” books, or by asking the “right” questions, or even by hearing the “right” speakers. The answers to this question will be spiritually deeper than that. On the journey, seekers uncover who they are now and who they are becoming under the Lordship of Christ. The destination is clear: Jesus as Lord over all of my life, even over my area of expertise.

Now, let me address the elephant in the room. Practically, how does living an integrated life, being both a professional academician and a faithful follower of Christ, manifest itself in a Christian mathematician? In attempting to answer this question for myself, I will use two phrases that are often heard in Christian higher education: “redeeming the discipline” and “thinking Christianly.” First of all, does “redeeming the discipline” entail changing or altering the content of the discipline? For the discipline of mathematics, I would argue no. Altering the discipline has not been part of my calling as a Christian mathematician. I conjecture that Christians in other disciplines may respond differently to this question. However, I want to argue that “redeeming the discipline” of mathematics could have at least two meanings for the Christian mathematician.

Firstly, “redeeming the discipline” of mathematics involves reinvigorating and prioritizing certain subareas within the discipline. These subareas (e.g. algebra, analysis, probability, geometry) are categorized by the contemporary mathematical society. Just as clothes can be either in or out of vogue, these subareas have received varying degrees of importance during different periods of time. My work involves the training of future Christian mathematicians, both teachers and researchers. Realizing that both of these groups lack a broad understanding of the human story of mathematics, I prioritize exposure to the history of mathematics for undergraduates. In a similar manner, regardless of current trends, another Christian mathematician might emphasize a different subarea of the discipline, accomplishing, at least in part, the mission of Christian higher education. Thus, we have one powerful method for “redeeming the discipline.” But there is another.

Secondly, I propose that “redeeming the discipline” of mathematics entails a return to the original source and purposes of this knowledge. Hardy equated intellectual curiosity with the desire to know the truth. I would argue that intellectual curiosity alone is insufficient and will lead to, at best, an incomplete version of the truth. The missing piece is context. First of all, the ability to do mathematics is a gift from God, and this should be acknowledged in our professional lives. We can debate until the end of time whether God is the author of none, some, or all of mathematics, but we as Christians cannot deny that God is our creator. So, regardless of one’s opinion on the origin of the discipline, God deserves the ultimate credit for the existence of mathematics. Then, responding to our God-given ability, we engage in the mathematical enterprise and become stewards and co-creators of knowledge in this world. This mathematical knowledge allows humans to comprehend aspects of the creation, to make predictions about the creation, and even to engage in thoughts we believe to be similar to, yet wholly different from, the Creator. Using the gifts of ratiocination and imagination, we can prove mathematical truths not only about this created order (reality), but also about abstract, idealized worlds that exist only in our minds, all to the glory of God.

Next Friday, Matt Lunsford will conclude this series of articles, originally part of one longer piece, by considering what it means to “think Christianly” and what questions this has led him to explore with colleagues and students.

Share this:

  • Email
  • Print
  • Facebook
  • More
  • Twitter
  • Tumblr
  • LinkedIn
  • Reddit
  • Pinterest

A Christian Mathematician’s Apology: Integrating Faith and Mathematics

JESHOOTS.com at Pexels

Last week, math professor  Matt Lunsford wrote about his journey of discerning his call to teach mathematics. This week, he describes what it means for him to be a “Christian mathematician” and what it means for him to live the integrated life.

______________________________________

Circa 1996, I embarked on a journey to discover and then to live out the integrated life. I realize that I have not arrived at the final destination. As with most journeys, a guide is invaluable. I found my mentor in a most unusual place – not among the living. English language scholar and Christian writer C. S. Lewis died before I was even born. Even though Lewis was not a mathematician, I have found him to be a marvelous guide and a kindred spirit. He was a first- rate academician who sought to live a life fully faithful to Jesus. Reading Lewis convinced me that I was on the road less traveled, but that I was not on this journey alone.

Let me begin unpacking my thoughts on the integrated life. Hardy asked two fundamental questions in his essay: First, is mathematics a worthwhile pursuit, and second, why would someone become a mathematician? He dispenses with his answers to the second question rather quickly and then spends most of the rest of the essay discussing his first question. Taking my cue from Hardy, I want to ask two questions that will guide the remainder of this essay. What is mathematics? What makes a Christian mathematician different from a secular mathematician?

What is mathematics? That question has been pondered by humans for at least two millennia. First of all, the term mathematics is derived from the ancient Greek word mathematos, which literally means “that which is to be learned.” So, historically, mathematics has been associated with those areas of knowledge that were deemed worthy of study. For the Pythagorean sect, this specifically meant the natural numbers and their properties, geometry, astrology (including astronomy), and music. These four subject areas formed the original quadrivium of the liberal arts. I do not know of a universally accepted definition of mathematics, but here is my current working definition: mathematics is the discovery, creation, proof, and rigorous communication of logical theories, encapsulated within a prescribed and mutually agreed upon axiomatic system. The ultimate goal of this activity is both the acquirement of results, known as mathematical truth, and the rigorous dissemination of those same results. This mathematical enterprise, which has been operational for over two thousand years, exists, at least in part, to enhance humanity’s understanding of the created order (reality) in which we find ourselves. While my definition might sound exotic, rest assured that I am describing the same well known discipline – the one which explores the properties of right triangles and provides formulas for solving quadratic equations and so forth.

What makes a Christian mathematician different from a secular mathematician? For me, it is not the mathematics. What I call the “kernel” of the discipline is exactly the same. By “kernel,” I mean the core of the discipline as it is understood and practiced by contemporary mathematicians. The content of the papers I write for scholarly journals and the talks I give at professional meetings are remarkably similar to those of a secular mathematician. However, as I am contemplating my discipline, I feel the freedom to explore whether ideas that emerge from my Christian faith commitment might enrich my understanding of mathematics, and alternately, whether the mathematical ideas I am pondering might enhance my understanding of the Christian faith. For example, Christian mathematicians might contemplate how the mathematical concept of infinity amplifies the meaning of eternal life. They might also investigate the relationship between mathematical truth and absolute truth. This freedom, I believe, is a substantive difference between the Christian and secular mathematician, but it is not the only one.

Another distinction is the source of our motivation. Why do we, as mathematicians, continue to learn, practice, and teach mathematics? Hardy asserts that the dominant motivations for the mathematician are intellectual curiosity, professional pride, and ambition. Christian educators like Parker Palmer have offered a partial retort to this mindset (To Know As We Are Known, 6-9). Pursuing mathematics primarily for curiosity equates to seeking knowledge for the sake of knowledge itself. Pursuing mathematics primarily for recognition equates to seeking knowledge for vanity. Pursuing mathematics primarily for utility equates to seeking knowledge for its power to control. (Hardy, who argued that his contributions to number theory were both useless and harmless, never sought to exploit his mathematical abilities in this way.) If, however, we pursue mathematics primarily for love, then we seek knowledge to heal a fallen world; that is, we seek knowledge to serve and edify others, to bring reconciliation and restoration to humanity, and also to glorify the Creator. Therefore I, and hopefully many other Christian mathematicians, strive to be motivated primarily by love.

Next week in part three of this series, Matt Lunsford offers  his idea about having a redeeming influence in the discipline of mathematics.

 

 

 

Share this:

  • Email
  • Print
  • Facebook
  • More
  • Twitter
  • Tumblr
  • LinkedIn
  • Reddit
  • Pinterest

A Christian Mathematician’s Apology: Finding My Vocation

Max Fischer at Pexels

We appreciate receiving this extended essay from Matt Lunsford, a professor at Union University. His story is a wonderful example of a journey of thinking Christianly about one’s field of study and work in academia. In this first of four parts, Matt describes how he discerned his calling to study and teach mathematics.

___________________________________________

The idea of writing about my goal of living an integrated life as a Christian mathematician grew out of a desire to respond to G. H. Hardy’s autobiographical essay A Mathematician’s Apology, originally published in 1940. While my experiences as a mathematician are similar in many ways to Hardy, I must acknowledge that I am not a research mathematician at one of the most prestigious institutions in the world. Even so, since being a mathematician has many universal similarities, I can relate well to most of Hardy’s comments. However, one significant distinction is that Hardy was a self-declared atheist. While many may believe that this distinction makes little to no difference in the professional life of a mathematician, I disagree, and that is my main purpose for writing this essay. It is my hope that by doing so, I might encourage fellow mathematicians, and possibly even academicians in other fields who hold to the Christian faith, to pursue the integrated life.

I have always had a natural ability to do mathematics. Throughout my school years, I was very good at arithmetic, algebra, and geometry. As an undergraduate, I did not select mathematics as a major until I took my first Calculus course. There was something about that course, with its epsilons and deltas, limits, derivatives, and integrals that I found fascinating. I recall being intrigued by the mathematical notion of the infinite. That was a new idea. However, most of my undergraduate mathematics career was simply thinking that mathematics was like a game of chess: just follow the rules and get the correct result. Near the end of that time, I was introduced to the idea of a mathematical proof. This was the next new idea, and it thrilled me. By this time, I was ready to try my luck at postgraduate education in mathematics.

Something dramatic happened in my first-year graduate courses in mathematics. My professors introduced me to abstract algebra, and in particular, to an area of algebra known as Galois theory. I already knew that I loved mathematics, but I fell head over heels in love with abstract algebra. Even today, I find the subject beautiful. I believe that passion, after ability, is probably the most important quality for becoming a mathematician. Passion was and continues to be the driving force for my becoming and remaining a mathematician.

Hardy and I agree that pursuing mathematics as a career is a noble goal, assuming that you are gifted and passionate about the subject matter. As for me, a career in mathematics was further confirmed by vocatio, a sense of calling. In my early years of college, I floundered. I was wrestling with a call to ministry, but I really did not know what that ministry would be. Now, after teaching for more than 25 years, I realize that my ministry is in undergraduate mathematics education, teaching students to love the discipline that I love. My vocation has been rewarding and fulfilling, but incorporating the integrated life into my career has remained a challenge.

Circa 1996, I embarked on a journey to discover and then to live out the integrated life. I realize that I have not arrived at the final destination. As with most journeys, a guide is invaluable. I found my mentor in a most unusual place – not among the living. English language scholar and Christian writer C. S. Lewis died before I was even born. Even though Lewis was not a mathematician, I have found him to be a marvelous guide and a kindred spirit. He was a first- rate academician who sought to live a life fully faithful to Jesus. Reading Lewis convinced me that I was on the road less traveled, but that I was not on this journey alone.

Matt Lunsford’s articles will appear the next three Fridays with a summary post to follow. In part two, he describes something of his process to integrate mathematics and his faith.

Share this:

  • Email
  • Print
  • Facebook
  • More
  • Twitter
  • Tumblr
  • LinkedIn
  • Reddit
  • Pinterest

Scholar’s Call: The Student Who Walked Away

walked away photo

In today’s Scholar’s Call piece, Paul Yandle meditates on how the experience of teaching shows him more about God, even in those moments when a student’s response is not what the professor was hoping for.  [Read more…] about Scholar’s Call: The Student Who Walked Away

Share this:

  • Email
  • Print
  • Facebook
  • More
  • Twitter
  • Tumblr
  • LinkedIn
  • Reddit
  • Pinterest

Scholar’s Call: The Joy of Becoming a Generalist

world map photo

The first day of the fall semester of my senior undergraduate year, I ran into a friend of mine, a fellow history major, outside of the student union building at the research university we attended. We stopped and talked for a bit, updating each other on our lives and comparing our fall schedules. My friend had just been to the university bookstore, and he showed me a textbook he had just bought for a History of the Old South class that the history department was offering that fall. Intrigued, I sat in on the class and became immediately hooked. I added the class to my schedule and soon decided that I wanted to pursue southern history as a career. That decision set the course for my graduate studies. I spent years immersing myself in the upper southeast—including seemingly endless hours immersing myself in the pertinent scholarly literature, as well as traveling to special collections and sitting in manuscript and microfilm rooms poring through primary sources. And I learned how to practice a discipline I really did not understand as an undergraduate. [Read more…] about Scholar’s Call: The Joy of Becoming a Generalist

Share this:

  • Email
  • Print
  • Facebook
  • More
  • Twitter
  • Tumblr
  • LinkedIn
  • Reddit
  • Pinterest
Next Page »

Primary Sidebar

Become a Member

Membership is Free. Sign up and receive our monthly newsletter and access ESN member benefits.

Join ESN Today

Scholar’s Compass Booklet

Scholar's Compass Booklet

Click here to get your copy

Top Posts

  • A Prayer for Those Finishing a Semester
  • Waiting: Preparation and Peacefulness within Our Hearts
  • Faith and Reason, Part 3: Aquinas
  • Faith and Reason, Part 2: Augustine
  • The Message of Genesis 1

Facebook Posts

Facebook Posts

Footer

Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy

Recent Posts

  • Waiting: Preparation and Peacefulness within Our Hearts
  • Aching: Justice and Shalom in Our World
  • Longing: Greatness and Grace in our Leaders

Article Categories