When I teach students to look at art, the first question I ask them is â€œwhat is it?â€ By this, I do not mean “what do you think you see?” but “what do you actually see?” – Sarah Awad, â€œArt Identity: Christian. Artist. Stranger.â€ In Faithful is Successful.
Sarah Awad is writing about art here, and her words are deeply relevant to Christian artists. But at the risk of wresting her words out of their context, I think thereâ€™s something academics outside the arts can learn from her reflections on how professional artists look at a painting or a sculpture. When we look at anythingâ€”a literary text, a chemical structure, an animal habitat, an account from historyâ€”do we try to see what it is, not just what we expect it to be?
Awad says that when many people view contemporary art, they miss something about it because they start not with the question â€œwhat is it doing?â€ but with the question â€œis it doing what I think it should be doing?â€ For instance, viewers may miss the pleasure of a great abstract if their only question is â€œWhy isnâ€™t this a realist portrait or landscape?â€ Awad leaves plenty of space for critical judgment and for personal taste in art, but she asks us to start first by trying to understand what the artist is doing and see if there is anything to appreciate there, before we ask if itâ€™s what we want art to be doing.
I can think of at least three areas where Christian academics have a similar choice to the one Awad describes:
1. Engaging with colleagues
In academic life, itâ€™s all too easy to make quick judgments about whether what a colleague is doing fits with our ideas of what our field should be doing. Awadâ€™s questions are a great reminder to learn from colleagues who may have a different methodological or theoretical view, or may be working on something that doesnâ€™t initially interest us. Even if we donâ€™t wind up agreeing, we can build relationships by listening well to colleagues, as David Vishanoff and Oli Marjot reminded us earlier in this series.
2. Engaging with students
I taught freshman English composition frequently while in graduate school, and itâ€™s quite easy to approach another research paper on internet gambling or school-related stress with a very clear grading template in mind. I did need to make it a priority in the class that papers fit certain expectations, such as responsible research practices and clear argumentation. But I found that things went better when I could think of the student first as a writer I had the gift of reading, and second as someone to whom I gave feedback. If I first tried to figure out what students were trying to do, and then gave feedback on how to do it more effectively, it was a better experience for everyone.
3. Engaging with the theory of a discipline
The famous theorists in a number of disciplines can seem (or actually be) pretty hostile to faith. There are absolutely times when we need to challenge a viewpoint courteously and courageously from our faith perspective. But seeing whatâ€™s actually there when we engage with a prevalent theory lets us learn a lot. Sometimes the theory is more open to faith than expected: after reading popular apologetics critiques of postmodernism in high school, I was surprised in graduate school to find the degree to which some postmodern theorists were making space for scholars to engage with faith. Thatâ€™s not to say I signed on for everything about postmodernism without critical engagement, but I came to see the aspects of postmodernism that welcome faith as well as the ones that challenge it.
Iâ€™ll never forget the evening we discussed Marxâ€™s Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844 in my great books seminar style MA program. Two students I knew to be major fans of capitalism were vocal in the discussion. One of the two wore a parody T-shirt to class with a Coca Cola style red and white design and the slogan â€œEnjoy Capitalism.â€ He spent most of the evening attacking Marx. The other student spent most of his time trying to figure out what Marx was actually doing in the text we were reading. His thoughtful questions and fairminded efforts to summarize the difficult text were a great service to the rest of the class. I think the first student was a Christian and the other student was a humanist, but the second studentâ€™s approach became a model I tried to live up to in my graduate studies. Because he was willing first to see things as they were and then to figure out how they fit with his own views, he supported the learning of the whole class. May we be willing to serve in this way too.
Where in your academic life could you ask, â€œWhat do I actually see?â€
Who in your academic life may need your listening and understanding?
Oh Lord, You who served others when You had every right to be served, who listened when You had every right to be heard, make us listeners and learners. Let us have eyes to see the people around us, the things in Your world, and the work of our hands. Through Christ our Lord we come to You. Amen.
Awad, Sarah. â€œArt Identity: Christian. Artist. Stranger.â€ Faithful is Successful. Faithful is Successful: Notes to the Driven Pilgrim. Nathan Grills, David E. Lewis, and S. Joshua Swamidass, eds. Denver, Colorado: Outskirts Press, 2014. 244-259.
Image courtesy of geralt at Pixabay.com
About the author:
Dr. Hannah Eagleson loves building the ecosystem Christian scholars need to flourish and create positive impacts, in the university and beyond. She is Associate Director of InterVarsityâ€™s Emerging Scholars Network, a digital first ministry serving thousands of early career Christian scholars. Dr. Eagleson launched the ESN student/early career track at the American Scientific Affiliation annual faith and science conference. She is the editor of *Science and Faith: Student Questions Explored* (Hendrickson, 2019), and the one-semester guidebook *Scholarâ€™s Compass: Connecting Faith & Work for Academics* (InterVarsity Emerging Scholars Network, 2021), with design by noted liturgical artist Ned Bustard. She also launched the Scholar's Compass online devotional series in her previous role as ESN Editor. Dr. Eagleson holds an MA from St. Johnâ€™s College (Annapolis, MD) and a PhD in Renaissance literature from the University of Delaware.